Brewing wheat beer (pt 3)
After five days in the fermenter, 38 gravity points of sugar have been transformed into something happier. As of this evening, the wheat beer is down to a specific gravity of 1.016, near the final gravity it’s likely to settle at. Beer has almost happened here!
One of the things I’d like to do is correlate fermentation activity with bubble rate a little more confidently. Now, absolute bubble rate is not comparable across fermenter setups, or even between batches, and perhaps not even between measurements which require the top to come off. There’s no hope of reliably saying something like “oh, 30 bubbles per second means that we’re fermenting out 8 points per day.” But it’s possible that we’ll be able to say that, in general, fermentation rate within a batch correlate pretty strongly with day-over-day change in specific gravity, that is, that more bubbles means more fermentation. The rate of bubbling depends on the volume of the headspace between the top of the beer and the bucket lid, on the level to which the airlock is filled with water, on precisely how tightly the bucket’s lid fits… but also, we hope to show, on the speed with which CO2 is being generated.
Here’s four days’ worth of measurements from this batch:
| Date | Bubbles/min | SG | ΔSG/day |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 May | N/a | 1.054 | N/a |
| 13 May | N/a | 1.050 | .004 |
| 14 May | 94 | 1.032 | .018 |
| 15 May | 33 | 1.024 | .008 |
| 16 May | 14 | 1.016 | .008 |
For the three bubble measurements available — a pretty thin data set, to be sure — the correlation coefficient between the bubble rate and the real fermentation rate (ΔSG/day) is 0.997, which is very significant, even more so than I expected. It will be interesting to see how it holds up with more measurements.

Abby:
wow, col. wow. just let me know when the beer is ready for drinking and i’ll fly out to partake
17 May 2007, 8:10 amColin:
I’m thinking that I’ll be bottling by Saturday at this rate, and it will take about five days to carbonate the beer. Feel free to aim for the weekend after next.
I’ve been thinking through my concerns about relying on the bubble rate as a useful absolute measurement… Bubble rate doesn’t actually depend on headspace volume; only the time to reach pressure equilibrium depends on that. Lid tightness is also probably a non-issue, as it is for all intents infinitely tighter than the airlock. The only parameter that matters, other than the gas output I want to measure, is the weight of the water sitting above the gas outlets in the airlock, and I can get that pretty well fixed on my model, which has a fill line. Maybe there’s something to bubble watching after all.
17 May 2007, 10:00 amAbby:
ok, well i might not make it out that soon. keep brewing this summer and make sure there is a perfect batch ready for me when i visit after Snowball is born
17 May 2007, 10:19 am